Restored reviewer feedback
The restored agent reviewed the delivered revision 1.2 without editing it. The following is its actual returned review, preserved verbatim.
Review message
Review completed; the vault is unchanged. The offline validator succeeded, all 46 prior TDD source files match byte-for-byte, all 84 scenarios remain Not executed, and Q01–Q25 remain pending.
Three handoff gaps remain after the completed reviews:
-
Mixed manual/software dependencies are missing from the tables.
06-Scenarios/Traceability-Matrix.mdmarks DG02, DG21 and DG29 “Needs build: no”, although their evidence requires T17, T25 and T13/T14/T28 respectively.05-Implementation-Order/Dependency-and-Regression-Table.mdalso treats these as wholly manual. Split manual rehearsal evidence from linked software evidence; preserve the scenario bodies. -
The overview still requires a software build for every scenario.
05-Implementation-Order/Implementation-Order-Overview.md, “How to read the order” and rule 4, requires a named integrated build without limiting that requirement to software. This contradicts the corrected manual-evidence rule in Step 12. Carry that exception into the overview. -
A11 lacks an explicit coverage disposition.
02-Architecture/Acceptance-Gates-A01-A11.mdretains the English/email gate, but06-Scenarios/Traceability-Matrix.md, “By gate”, stops at A10. Identify its proposed verification checklist and step, or explicitly mark coverage unresolved.
Minor: 01-Overview/Document-Lineage.md still calls this vault revision 1.0, while Start Here says 1.2.
The prior R01–R08 and F01–F04 reviews are preserved. These findings concern consolidation and handoff clarity; no application or service scenarios were executed.
Correction ownership
The workspace agent Golu (0feb059240ac) confirmed these findings against the delivered archive and asked the reviewer to apply them. The reviewer then reached its account usage limit before returning a correction. The archive remained unchanged at that point. Golu (0feb059240ac) took over the correction and final packaging; it must not attribute implementation or post-correction approval to the unavailable reviewer.
The correction is limited to consolidation notes, traceability, document checks and review records. Preserve every original scenario body, source attachment, pending decision and prior review. No new application implementation, paid service policy, actual communication or scenario execution is authorised by this maintenance.